A reminder to all those Washingtonians who are currently excavating cars and sidewalks that Snowmaggedon has been visited upon Washington many, many times before...
Nineteenth and early Twentieth Century journalists loved a good mystery. Apparently, so do some Twentieth Century bloggers.
The Washington Post of May 10, 1904, carried the following tale of a mysterious stranger:
On a cold and blustery night in the mid 1860s, a cold and starving stranger knocked on the door of Georgetown’s Franklin Inn at 168 Bridge Street—later, 3249 M Street--asking for food and shelter. Innkeeper Ann Cleveland was the widow of John Cleveland, who had died in a tragic accident at the WashingtonMonument construction site. Sympathetic to the man, she ordered her servants to give him food and a place to lie down for the night. She told him not to leave in the morning until she had had a chance to speak with him.
The next morning, she offered the man, who called himself John Brown, a job as a general handyman. He accepted the offer and ended up working there, according to the Post, for two decades until Mrs. Cleveland’s death in 1888.
Mrs. Cleveland, prior to her death, had instructed her daughter Louisa Phipps to provide for Mr. Brown and, on his death, give him a respectable Christian burial.
Mr. Brown died at ProvidenceHospital in May, 1904, and true to her word, Louisa arranged for Father Smythe from St. Joseph’s Church on Capitol Hill to preside over the funeral. She buried John Brown in the family plot at HolyRoodCemetery in Georgetown.
Mr. Brown was as much a mystery to the family and neighbors at his death as he had been in life. He had appeared to be an educated man from a good family. He never divulged a single detail about his past, no matter how much pressure he was put under. He kept to himself, never making friends with either men or women.
The Post fancifully hinted he may have been connected to the infamous abolitionist by the same name—but of course, this would have been impossible, as the famous John Brown had been put to death in December, 1859.
Census returns show John Cleveland in Georgetown as early as 1840. The 1870 census shows a widowed Mrs. Cleveland and her children, as well as several servants and staff—among them, three Johns: Sweeney, Whelan and Haines, but no Brown. The 1880 census shows a plasterer named John Fowler.
No John Brown is listed in the tombstone transcripts of HolyRoodCemetery, though further examination of burial records held at GeorgetownUniversity may reveal his name.
Some years ago, the author read an account of a wild man who lived in a cluster of rocks on the Virginia side of Long Bridge, and she has been collecting tales of these “half men-half beasts” ever since. Most of these savages have simply turned out to be homeless indigents or aged victims of dementia.
The following is one of her favorites:
In July of 1894, farmers in Tennallytown began reporting having seen a half-naked man roaming the pastures and byways of their village, ranting as if he were wild. A local butcher reported seeing a white man of heavy build running through the woods just south of old River Road. When he called out, the running man simply shook his fist. The same day, a milkman on Conduit Road, about a mile and a half away, caught sight of a half-clad man running on his property. He thought it was a joke.
Streetcar No. 5 Motorman W. M. Vogt reported that while on a run through Tennallytown, he saw the wild man running down the middle of the road, flailing and threatening to tear up the track. Later, on a return trip, Vogt saw him crouching by the track. As the car passed, the wild man scurried away with a speed impossible for a drunk.
When a guest at the Woodley Inn claimed he saw the wild man in a ravine outside his window, authorities began to sit up and take notice.
Citizens began to talk about forming a posse to track down the wild man, but their efforts were hindered by rain over the next few days.
Police had found a pile of clothes in a ravine behind the Woodley Inn—a dark grey serge vest and coat and a brand-new straw hat. They joked that these likely belonged to someone too embarrassed to claim them.
Word of the wild man was beginning to spread. Housewives, who stayed at home alone during the day, became nervous. Though no one had been harmed by the wild man, the newspapers reported that there was no telling what he was capable of. It was supposed he subsisted on nuts and berries he found in the woods.
Concerned citizens checked with the mental asylum to see whether any inmate had escaped. None had.
Tennallytown resident Edward Brooks claimed his black servant had come across the wild man sleeping in the brush on the side of the road: The latter wore only “pantaloons", i.e., boxers, and a pair of worn socks, as well as several days’ growth of whiskers.
Patrolman Lohmann was sent to look for the wild man, who had by that time absconded.
Next, a carpenter who lived near Woodley Inn told mounted officers Heide and Murphy he had sighted the wild man just south of the Inn.
Under pressure from a nervous public, police arrested a black man named George Douglas, a hitherto harmless Tennallytown resident who was said to be nearly insane with grief over the death of his wife two years earlier. It was doubtful he was the “wild man,” in spite of his light complexion, because the clothes found in the woods were far too large for him.
Late on the evening of July 23, the night watchman in the powerhouse of the Tennallytown Electric Railroad Company heard an “unearthly shriek” from the engine room. Workers searched the building twice—and twice more heard the “demonic yell,” but found nothing and no one. They returned to the office, their hair standing on end. Perhaps the sound had come from outside, for there was no sign of forced entry into the powerhouse, and all its doors and windows were locked tight.
Then, just as suddenly as the wild man had appeared, he disappeared—for at least a few days. Locals theorized that the rain had forced him to seek cover in a local barn. Some believed he may have died from exposure or hunger. Search parties were called off. Tennallytown women and children breathed a sigh of relief.
And then on the afternoon of July 25, a man who called himself Mr. Lamb walked into the Seventh Precinct station house and asked for his clothes. Yes, he said, he was the wild man who had been terrorizing the vicinity. He blamed his antics on the kind of insanity that comes in a bottle.
It seems that Mr. Lamb had gone into the country some time in the preceding week, carrying with him “a large load of vinous stimulants.” He didn’t remember anything else, save for waking up to find himself nearly naked. He hitched a ride on the wagon of a butcher who he met on the road.
Officers told him his clothes had been sent to police headquarters and would be sent for immediately. Lamb could claim his clothes the next day. When he did, he announced that the hat they presented him was not his original $3.50 hat, but one of a much more inferior quality. Police believed that the officer who delivered the clothing from downtown headquarters had exchanged his own inferior hat for Mr. Lamb’s hat. They promised to keep their eyes on Officer Hauptman, just in case he should ever show up with a new straw hat.
If you were a policeman in Georgetown during the latter half of the nineteenth century, there was one assignment that would fill your heart with dread: Patrolling Cherry Hill, a rundown and disreputable neighborhood of alleys along the C&O Canal south of Bridge Street—today’s M Street, NW.
If you believed the papers and tales shared among officers in the Georgetown Precinct House, every policeman who had ever been assigned to patrol “Spooks’ Alley” had either died or suffered disaster and misfortune.
Police Officer [Samuel] Frank Burrows had been on the force for many years and told anyone who would listen that he’d rather resign the force than ever again walk the grim alleys around Cherry Street. It was haunted; plenty of folks had seen the ghost. He would appear every night, whether in summer or winter, just after St. John’s bells finished pealing twelve midnight: A phantom policeman wearing a heavy winter uniform, his collar pulled up to his ears. Whenever one of the officers would approach him—and few dared—he would disappear.
It was Dead Man’s Beat that had turned his hair white overnight.
In the beginning, Burrows didn’t believe in ghosts or spooks and thought less of his colleagues for being so gullible—that is until one evening when he was sent to the haunted beat. He didn’t get further than Thirty-second and M Street before he turned around and beat a hasty retreat to the station house. He begged to his lieutenant to either reassign him or dismiss him, for he was determined not to ever patrol the area again. He had seen the ghost in every conceivable shape, sightings so terrifying that he wished he had never been born.
The next day, Burrows woke up with snow-white hair.
And the officer who had been sent to replace him on the beat was found dead.
This is the inauguration procession of the 25th President of the USA, William McKinley. This is the first sitting president to be filmed.
This clip was filmed on March 4, 1897 and follows the Procession down Pennsylvania Avenue in Washington D.C.
This clip, which is in the public domain, is from the Motion Picture Division of the U.S. National Archives and is made available by the good folks of the Internet Archive.
Her family was as old as Georgetown itself—even older than that. Emily—or Emma--Magruder was the daughter of Nathanial Magruder, whose Scottish ancestor Alexander had immigrated to Maryland as early as 1652. For generations, the name Magruder was synonymous with wealth, and Magruders had been among the first landowners in the City of Washington.
Emily Magruder was born in the mid-1840s and spent her entire life in same house at 1304 35th Street, near N, and close to HolyTrinityChurch. One of the oldest houses in Georgetown, by the early 1920s it had grown so dilapidated that its paint was peeling and in places, its roof had begun to cave in. Emma’s sole brother, Charles, and two of her sisters—Kate and Virginia—had died years earlier. Nothing is known of her sister Blanche, who died in the 1930s.
Emily lived alone and had done so since the turn of the century. Neighbors rarely saw her—she was considered an eccentric, and their opinion was only confirmed by the fact that the rare times when she left the house, she did not use the front door; instead, she climbed in and out of a front window.
Early in the 1920s, the city of Washington condemned the aging house and presumably warned Emily she would have to leave. However, when demolition crews arrived to do their work, the aging spinster was so vocal in her resistance that the workers left and never returned.
In early 1929, Emily made a decision that would later baffle authorities. She simply picked up and left her house and belongings and moved into the District’s poorhouse. Officially named the Washington Home for the Aged and the Infirm, it was a located at the southernmost tip of Washington’s 8th Ward, an area called Blue Plains. The Home sat on over a hundred acres, comprising an infirmary, schools for both whites and blacks, a complex of cottages, and assorted other buildings that would one day become the notorious DC Village.
It the time of its establishment, it was billed as a haven of fresh air and sunshine, where residents could farm and grow their own vegetables and have plenty of fresh milk from the cows that grazed there. That, at least, was the story given to the public. The truth was that the Board of Charities’ appropriations were so meager that the Infirmary amounted to little more than a Dickensian work farm. Buildings were flimsy in design and material; furnishings were sparse; staff was insufficient to tend for a growing number of inmates. As results, almost since its founding, the Home’s reputation had been blemished by reports of poor standards of living, abuse and worse. By the 1940s, a shocked Eleanor Roosevelt would announce, “It is sad and horrible if we are going to let Blue Plains be our standard for the nation on the attitude to old age.”
By the summer of 1929, neighbors began to notice frequent comings and goings at the Magruder house and complained to police. In August, the Washington Post reported that officers of the Seventh Precinct had arrested eleven individuals who had ransacked the house and stolen approximately $1,000 in cash.
As it turns out, that was only a fraction of the fortune Emily had hidden both in the house and its gardens.
When Precinct Detective Norman S. Nodkinson, accompanied by Officers William O’Connor and Charles C. Clay, entered the house, they were stunned to find it furnished with antiques and other curios, including large oil paintings copied after old Masters. They discovered more than $600 in old currency and silver coins, hidden under stacks of papers, in books or in cracks in the rotting walls. In addition, Emily had reportedly buried a strongbox containing a “small fortune” in a well in the back garden. All in all, it was rumored, Emily secreted away approximately $40,000—money she made, it was said, through investments of her early savings.
Here is where the narrative begins to twist: The story was first reported on August 16, 1929. However, cemetery records show that Emily Magruder had been buried March 13, 1917, twelve years earlier. The only Magruder sister still alive in 1929 would have been Blanche, who doesn’t show up as buried until 1934.
Could police and neighbors have been mistaken about the elderly Miss Magruder’s identity? Could Blanche have simply assumed her sister’s identity so as to retain the house and investments?
The plot began to thicken.
And ten days later, it was revealed that it was indeed Blanche who had been living in the ancient manse on Thirty-fifth Street. Her niece, Ms. Marie Clarke, had stepped forth and hired an attorney to represent Miss Magruder; plans were underway to remove her from the poor house at Blue Plains and place her in a private institution.
Meanwhile, police continued to comb the house, which was reputed to still be listed under the ownership of Blanche’s father, Mr. Nathaniel Magruder, who had died many years before. Neighbors gossiped that Nathaniel had left a rumored $40,000 in cash to the spinsters in cash—but police had so far recovered only about $4,000, stashed in the most incongruous of hiding places. That, combined with the approximate $5,000 value of the house, would be enough to ensure that Blanche would be cared for until the end of her days.
What happened to Blanche after that is not known. And Emily, as it turns out, had indeed died in 1917—as an inmate at St. Elizabeth’s Mental Asylum.
One evening in mid-June of 1892, a Georgetown police officer named Sullivan {likely, Thomas Sullivan) passed a forlorn little house on Valley Street—that is, present-day 32nd Street, between R and P. The house was back from the street; unruly trees and bushes nearly obscured it from the view of passersby. Sullivan had passed the house innumerable times on previous rounds, but tonight, he thought it looked more desolate than ever. Something was wrong.
He knocked on the door and called out. He heard a moan from inside, so he forced open the door. In the dim light inside, he found an elderly man sitting unconscious in a chair, where it turned out he had been sitting for two days.
Sullivan carefully lifted the man from the chair and carried him to a crude bed. He found a bottle of liquor and some water in a cupboard, with which he revived the old man.
Sullivan sent for Dr. Abraham Shekell, who lived just around the corner on 32nd Street. They learned the names and addresses of two relatives from Maryland—a Mrs. Franklin of Baltimore and an Edward Ghant (Gannt?) of Annapolis, who the papers reported to be a Maryland State’s Attorney. Chanler’s niece and nephew engaged outside help to look after the man. Finally, they decided that the crumbling house was not livable. So they sent their uncle to Garfield Hospital, a charitable institution erected only a few years before.
Presumably, Chanler lived out the rest of his days there. No records can be found of either his life or his death in Washington, in spite of a plethora of details provided by newspapers at the time:
According to those reports, Chanler was 86 years old and had lived like a hermit for years. At the break of the Civil War, he had been a senior “Captain” in the United States Navy—“outranking” even the famous Naval war hero, David Dixon Porter, and others. His heart was said to lie with the South, but because he couldn’t think of any way of honorably resigning from the Navy, he remained and distinguished himself by capturing “five of the first prizes taken from the Confederacy.”
At some point during the War, Chanler reportedly broke down and went South. He allegedly returned to Washington a broken man.
There are far too many William Chanlers/Chandlers in census and military records to ever be able to pinpoint the exact man found languishing in Georgetown.
Interestingly, a William Chandler served as Secretary of the Navy from 1882 to 1885; there is, however, no chance that our Georgetown hermit was this distinguished gentleman.
Geier Hertzog Ingersoll Jenkins Johnson Kiefer Killeen Kiefer
Leahy
Linthicum
Magruder
Murdock
Mussey Noack
Nodkinson
Oppenheimer
Pearson
Pugh
Register
Rickey
Sedgwick
Shekell
Sinkfield/Singfield
Shoomaker
Spurgeon
Sunderland Towle Walker Wynne
& So Many More!
Caveat
Updates, corrections and addenda added regularly. Stay tuned for more photos.
Why Quondam Washington?
quon·dam
(kwän′dəm, -dam) 1. [a] belonging to some prior time ; "erstwhile friend"; "our former glory"; "the once capital of the state"; "her quondam lover".
I was born in Georgetown, as were generations of my paternal ancestors. I was raised not on stories of Washington's Founders and Glorious Politicians, but on stories of regular folks-butchers, hucksters and firemen. When we gathered as a family, we didn't discuss the latest political scandals, but tales of murders, suicides, ghosts, religious miracles...
From a very young age, I was fascinated by Washington's other history and have been collecting these tales for years.
Sometimes when I drive downtown, I go into a sort of fugue state, in which I almost see the shadows of the folks who long ago walked its streets. I can hear the sound of taffeta petticoats whooshing, of footsteps in cobbled alleys and the clopping of horses hooves. I can smell good steaks sizzling at the old Leeches Buffet and the odor of the pigs that once rummaged in the city's gutters. I can walk down certain streets and point to buildings: "This was an oyster bar, this was a glove shop, here's where Madame Carlette read palms for a quarter, here's where Ada Paynce sold cast-iron corsets and Abner Drury brewed Old Glory Beer.
I am old enough to remember Georgetown before its gentrification was complete--stumbling over loose bricks in the sidewalks, turning our noses the other way when the fumes from the bone rendering plant along the waterfront turned north from the riverfront.
This is the Washington I seek to present in this blog--and I welcome both your comments and your own memories.
* Credits, Main Blog Image:
Panoramic View of WashingtonCity: from the new dome of the Capitol, looking east/drawn from nature and print in colors by E. Sachse & Co. Published by Casimir Bohn, c1857. Copyright by E. Sachse & Co. Courtesy Library of Congress Prints and Photographs DivisionWashington, D.C.20540USA